@tgerring wants to not spend so much time planning the doc, but to get it done in a way that is easily consumable to the wider Ethereum ecosystem with a focus on Ethereum newcomers.
@alexvandesande wants there to be clear separation from the homestead guide and website tutorials.
@frozeman wants there to be solid reasoning to switching platforms and overhauling the guide. He wants to make sure people can easily contribute from the community with no barriers of entry. He wants to keep much of the specific or technical documentation on the wiki until there is clear community consenses it should all be moved.
@zelig would prefer moving nearly all wiki content to the homestead guide, but understands the issues at hand and is aiming for as little cross reference as possible.